new banner 2
 
 
 Web  Ramona Sentinel 
?
BIA has no answer in track brouhaha
ABOUT THE AUTHOR

   A response from a federal agency regarding the Barona Noise and Pollution Action Committee’s (BNPAC) complaints about the Barona Oaks Motocross track still leaves unanswered questions for affected residents of San Diego Country Estates (SDCE).
   Last week the Sentinel published an article about the BNPAC’s frustration over a lack of response from the many government officials it has contacted in an effort to abate the noise and air pollution that some Estates residents say they experience on a daily basis. A portion of the Estates abuts the Barona Indian Reservation and residents say that over the years a mini-motorcycle track has grown to include the motocross track, a drag strip and other venues, with larger motorcycles and more hours of operation causing excessive noise and air pollution from the emissions.
   In December, Congressman Duncan Hunter sent a letter to the Southern California Agency of the U.S. Bureau of Indian Affairs, inquiring what actions, if any, the BIA would consider necessary in this situation. The BIA responded in a letter to Hunter stating it had reviewed correspondence from SDCE residents along with supporters of the MX track. The BIA  said the Barona Band of Mission Indians (BMI) had provided the agency with information sent to U.S. Sen. Dianne Feinstein that included a brief history of the track and the BMI’s efforts to work with their neighbors.
   “As you know, the track is a tribally owned enterprise and is regulated by BMI,” the letter from the Southern California Agency of BIA stated.  “The BIA does not have jurisdiction over the maintenance and operation of the track. In response to your question regarding a request and/or action against BMI, the BIA has no basis in which to request the United States Attorney to pursue an investigation as there are no federal actions pending from BIA. Compliance and/or issues pertaining to the track would be resolved through the tribal chain-of-command.”
   Marshall Kelsay, chairman of the BNPAC, responded with a letter to Hunter’s office, stating he is confused over the BIA’s comment that it has no jurisdiction over the track.
   “However, the BIA has jurisdiction over the entire Barona Indian Reservation, which makes their point rather ludicrous,” he said. “Does the BIA mean to represent that, as long as BMI has leased activities on their property, they cannot be held responsible for those activities?”
   Kelsay said that doesn’t work in the rest of the United States and he questioned why the federal government allows the sovereign nation status to shield the Indian reservation from any type of regulation and/or conformity that is required of non-Indians.
   Asking Hunter to unequivocally state that residents have no rights or further available options with the federal government or the congressman’s office in regard to the issue, Kelsay said he will be asking the same of other public officials to whom he has written.
   “Professionally I clearly understand bureaucracy and the merry-go-round theory of no one ever being accountable and shift the responsibility from one agency to the other,” Kelsay said. 
   Kelsay said he has also been in contact with Feinstein’s office, but has never received a response from the senator.
Post A Comment
* Indicates required information
Comment Title:
* Comments:
Nickname:
* Validation:
Comments 4 comments for this article
Added: January 19, 2010. 11:36 AM
SDCE 4 BARONA
"Though I no longer live in Ramona, I was a resident for close to 20 years. The motocross track has been there forever, and it is on an Indian Reservation. Those Estates folks knew the track was there before they ever built or bought their house. "
YES YES YES When I bought my house I SIGNED!!

Its called DO YOUR DUE DILIGENCE People! If you dont like it dont buy it.

This is really ludacrous.
SDCE Homeowner
Added: January 17, 2010. 10:06 AM
Seek Professional Consultation
This is a very complicated situation. It would be a very good idea to seek out a professional consultant who can discuss best practices for working with Native American communities.
Anonymous
Added: January 15, 2010. 07:13 AM
They Knew About This
Though I no longer live in Ramona, I was a resident for close to 20 years. The motocross track has been there forever, and it is on an Indian Reservation. Those Estates folks knew the track was there before they ever built or bought their house.

It's almost like those people who buy a house near an airport, only to complain about the noise from the airplanes.

The people in the Estates need to leave the tracks alone and move on. You bought a house near a recreation facility, get over it!!!
Tyrone
Added: January 14, 2010. 08:48 PM
Barona Indians are LIARS!
It's a very simple definition: LIAR –noun: a person who tells lies. LIE: something intended or serving to convey a false impression

The Barona Tribe are LIARS! They produce fancy full color brochures where they claim to be great neighbors and great stewards of the Earth. We are their neighbors, and the Barona Tribe will not even talk to us or come to our homes to listen to the noise, despite repeated invitations. How is a motocross track in the bottom of a sensitive streambed good for the Earth? How does terrorizing your neighbor with noise 5 days a week, 8+ hours a day make you a good neighbor? The county performed a sound study, and the noise is well above the 55 decibel limit considered tolerable.

Their brochures are produced to convey a false impression, therefore, the Barona Tribe are LIARS.

When many of us bought our homes, the track was a tiny little place for kids on minibikes, operated two weekends per month, 6 months out of the year. Now, the facility is TWO tracks, operated year-round, Wed-Sun, from 9 am until sundown, with motorcycles that produce sound in excess of 120 decibels, as tested by a leading motorcycle publication. 120 decibels is rock-concert level.

The track has changed from when we bought here, and the Barona Indians know this. Why is the track located as far away as possible from their own homes? If the track is such a great idea, why isn't it next to the casino, where there is plenty of parking, lodging, food, and spectators? The permitting for the casino area includes recreation, right? Otherwise, how could there be a golf course there? I wish Chairman Romero would answer these questions, or at least come to our homes during a real event, and listen to what his tribe is putting us through.

If the Barona Tribe weren't such liars, they would help their neighbors and the Earth, and close the track to relocate it next to the casino, where it wouldn't bother the neighbors, and it wouldn't be in the bottom of a streambed.

I challenge the Barona Tribe to do the right thing, prove they are NOT liars, and close this track and move it to the casino, so we can all live in peace.

Read more and listen here: http://badtrack.bravehost.com/
Sam Klondike
Google
Article Popularity
Views
Comments